Observing that a detailed hearing by an appropriate bench is required, the Supreme Court on Friday refused to pass an interim order at this stage staying various notifications issued under the Aadhaar Act to make unique identity number mandatory for several social welfare schemes.
Rohatgi said that Aadhaar was being made compulsory so that benefits of schemes do not "go to ghosts".
Recusing from hearing the matter, the vacation bench said that the matter would be listed before an appropriate bench.
Appeals court strikes down FAA drone registration rule
Jonathan Rupprecht, a lawyer working with Taylor, considers the ruling a victory for the semantics of what a hobby drone is. The ruling is a win for model aircraft enthusiasts who complained that the registration requirement was too burdensome.
However, the bench asked "why this second petition when you have already filed a plea earlier seeking similar reliefs".
Rohatgi said that earlier, some pleas seeking identical interim reliefs were also filed and those matters were pending before the apex court. He also requested that the case be referred to the two-judge bench appointed to hear urgent cases during the summer vacation.
As Rohatgi said that even the present petition should be heard by the constitution bench, Divan wondered why he was fighting shy of hearing of the matter on merits. "Now, no other bench except the constitution bench can take up this matter", he said. "The matter needed to be heard urgently", Divan had told the court ahead of today's hearing.
National Safe Boating Week is May 20 - 26
Make sure navigation lights work properly. "If you don't have them, you're not going to last long". Give them phone numbers for the local emergency dispatch center and U.S.
When the court asked Divan whether the orders passed by the three-judge and five-judge bench earlier were not serving the goal, the senior counsel replied "they (Centre) are violating those orders".
"They are in breach of it", senior counsel Shyam Divan told the bench as it inquired from Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi about the assurance given by the Centre that it would not share with anyone the biometric information given by people at the time of applying for Aadhaar card.
He said if a person does not have Aadhaar till June 30, he can get himself enrolled for it and enrollment slips and slips of request made for it would also serve the objective.
MI teen visiting NY killed in Times Square crash
Richard Rojas, 26, appeared subdued during a brief court appearance where prosecutors detailed a felony murder charge. The fire department said earlier that 22 people were injured, but police on Friday said the number was 20.
Strongly opposing the petition, Mr Rohatgi made it clear that the government was not going to extend the deadline of June 30 by which various schemes such as grant of scholarships, Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan and various other social welfare schemes were to seek mandatory Aadhaar number. The bench, Justices A M Khanwilkar and Navin Sinha, said it would hear all petitions against making Aadhaar compulsory for various schemes to avoid multiplicity. The apex court had earlier on October 15, 2015 permitted the voluntary use of Aadhaar cards for welfare schemes like MGNREGA, all pension schemes, the provident fund and the "Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojna" in addition to LPG and PDS schemes.
- Analysts Perspectives: Novavax Inc (NASDAQ:NVAX)
- Boy found dead in mother's stolen car; 3 teens arrested
- United States and China Take First Steps in Trade Deal
- It would happen abroad - Allardyce backs Mourinho's Premier League gripe
- Conservatives make strong gains in United Kingdom local votes
- Paytm bags Dollars 1.4 billion funding by SoftBank
- White House denies Trump asked Comey to pledge loyalty
- Kushners apologize for name-dropping Jared to Chinese investors
- PTI blames Sharif for ICJ stay of Jadhav execution
- Putin to France's Macron: Let's 'overcome mutual mistrust'